Cauvery dispute: Who is responsible for loss of assets at some point of agitations?

With protests intensifying in Karnataka and Tamil Nadu over the Cauvery River water-sharing dispute, both states have seen massive public and private property destruction. Together with country shipping buses, scores of cars were torched in Bengaluru because the city erupted in violence over sharing Cauvery waters with neighboring Tamil Nadu. A mob hurled stones and vandalized shops and establishments at a bus station for Tamil Nadu-certain buses, at the same time as a fleet of more than 30 buses belonging to a personal operator reportedly set on fire. In Chennai, a set of unidentified men allegedly hurled a petrol bomb at New Woodlands Motel, a Udupi eating place. The destruction of public assets is joint for the duration of agitations led by the utilization of prepared mobs.

Mint said that the Jat agitation in February has dealt an anticipated blow of Rs.18,000-20,000 crore through loss to public and private assets and halting alternate, industry, small enterprise, and delivery, according to the Related Chambers of Commerce and Industry (Assocham).


How can we restore duty for damage to belongings during agitations?

Following the Patel agitation in Gujarat last year, the Perfect Courtroom has decided to pass a law fixing accountability for the harm caused to public assets during agitations.

“You cannot burn the usa’s or its citizen’s belongings. Agitators can’t take u . S . at ransom,” the Courtroom had stated even as hearing a bail plea through Hardik Patel, a political activist from Gujarat who campaigned for the inclusion of the Patidar caste inside the different backward elegance (OBC) category.

Patel has been charged with sedition for inciting violence in the country that caused a lack of lifestyle and belongings. In 2009, taking an extreme note of numerous times, where there was big-scale destruction of public and private properties at some stage in agitations, bandhs, and hartals, the apex Courtroom initiated suo moto complaints to lay down the regulation-making those responsible answerable for their acts. The Courtroom formulated two committees—one headed by former apex Court decide Ok.T. Thomas and every other utilizing endorse Fali S. Nariman—which protected representatives of the home ministry and the law ministry.

Also Examine: Cauvery dispute: SC order sparks violence across Karnataka

One of the recommendations made through the committees was to amend the Prevention of Damage to Public Assets Act, 1984, o


The PDPP Act encompasses provisions that require the organization’s leaders to take direct action to be responsible for the abetment of the offense. “As long as there is no clean, identifiable leader calling for violence and incitement, it is going to be tough to pin obligation as mob mentality ensues. Until someone is determined manifestly violating police orders, then the organization’s chief could be liable,” stated Alok Prasanna Kumar, a senior resident fellow at the Vidhi Centre for Criminal Coverage.

The issue of figuring out the leaders has been a matter of remembering dialogue.

Advised Kapil Sibal, who regarded Hardik Patel inside the apex Courtroom, said that although Patel turned into the face of the agitation and called for movement, he can’t be held accountable. He had informed the Court that the protest quickly spiraled out of Patel’s management, and character protesters took to the streets, destroying assets. A three-judge bench of the apex court laid down hints in 2009 primarily based on the committee’s guidelines, which the Court is presently revisiting in the case of sedition made against Patel.

Explorer. Beer trailblazer. Zombie expert. Internet lover. Unapologetic introvert. Alcohol fanatic. Tv ninja.Once had a dream of buying and selling sauerkraut in Ohio. Practiced in the art of building crickets in Nigeria. Gifted in donating wooden tops in Fort Walton Beach, FL. Spent 2001-2007 testing the market for corncob pipes for no pay. A real dynamo when it comes to managing catfish in Jacksonville, FL. Spent a year investing in yard waste for farmers.

Forgot Password